Welcome at RacingNews365

Become part of the largest racing community in the United Kingdom. Create your free account now!

  • Share your thoughts and opinions about F1
  • Win fantastic prizes
  • Get access to our premium content
  • Take advantage of more exclusive benefits
Sign in

Why axing Sargeant would be a disservice to F1

Logan Sargeant's rookie season has been far from easy sailing, but ousting him after one campaign would be wrong for Williams and Formula 1.

In modern-day Formula 1, rookie drivers have an almost impossible task. With limited testing prior to the start of a season, they are thrust into an uphill battle to get on top of a category in which they have little experience. The ruthlessness of the F1 driver cycle was displayed just days after the British Grand Prix in mid-July when Nyck de Vries was dropped from AlphaTauri. Despite his abundance of racing experience, the Dutchman couldn’t forge a sense of stability alongside Yuki Tsunoda and paid the price just months after he realised his dream of being handed an F1 seat. With de Vries out of the way, the F1 scope moved to seek out its next target - and it now seems to be settled on Logan Sargeant. Rookie drivers are normally handed some leverage due to their lack of experience and Sargeant had been given some through his opening run of races. Few expected the American driver to beat Alexander Albon, with the latter easily having the measure of his teammate so far this year. Sargeant is yet to better Albon over one lap in qualifying and is still awaiting his maiden points in F1, while Albon has bagged five points finishes, with a best of seventh in Canada and Italy. Tangible progress appeared to be made on Sargeant’s side at the Dutch Grand Prix, when for the first time this campaign, he progressed into the Q3 segment of qualifying. Williams' had surprising pace around the narrow and twisting circuit, which was expected to challenge the FW45 package where the strength is largely straight-line speed. Sargeant's effort to advance into Q3 was hailed but only minutes later he was being scorned when he spun on the exit of Turn 2 at Zandvoort and crunched into the barrier. The disappointment for Sargeant was evident in his body language, and his mistake fit into the aptly named ‘rookie mistake’ category. His Sunday didn’t go much better as on lap 16, he crashed once again - although on this occasion, a hydraulic failure that stripped away his steering was to blame.

What does Sargeant say?

"It's a terrible feeling," Sargeant tells media including RacingNews365. "Mainly for, of course, the damage and every individual who helped get the car ready for Sunday, just to have it undone, it's terrible." Sargeant’s offs at Zandvoort weren’t his first of the year and more than likely won’t be the last, as it’s the territory that comes with being a rookie driver. But being an F1 novice today comes with a huge weight - with no in-season testing and just a day and a half of pre-season running to get up to speed, a deep investigation into why Sargeant and de Vries before him have struggled is not needed. While the third rookie in Oscar Piastri had much more preparation through private tests on the build-up to his F1 career, he too is predictably behind the performance of teammate Lando Norris. It’s a stark contrast to decades gone by when open testing and private outings were more prevalent - but in today’s cost-saving world, such exploitations are not possible. Rookies then, are left to learn during grand prix weekends, which is a task made even harder by F1 with the injection of sprint weekends, which allows for just 60 minutes of practice before being thrust into competitive sessions. "It's been one of the trickiest years I've ever driven in terms of conditions," Sargeant admitted. "Even in the past from F3 and F2, this has been a tricky one. "But at the end of the day, you're going have to go through these conditions at some point. To get the experience now, you don't learn unless you're outside of your comfort zone."

Will Sargeant get time?

Sargeant's comments also paint the picture that rookie drivers have to be more mentally strong than ever before in the quest to retain their seats. There's always someone viable waiting in the wings to snap the drive of an underperformer. Is it now considered more of a burden than an exciting look to the future to field a rookie? With such little practice time, first-year drivers must now, more than ever, be considered long-term investments. With question marks being placed over Sargeant’s head regarding his future, one season can’t be enough to grasp the full picture of his potential as he continues to adjust himself into a racing world that is vastly different from anything he's experienced. But luckily for Sargeant, Williams appears to recognise that. "James [Vowles, Williams Team Principal] has been there to support me since the start. He's still there to support me," Sargeant continues. "He keeps giving me good advice, keeps helping me move in the right direction. It's not an ideal situation. But at the end of the day, you have to put it in a box, close it, take the learnings from it and just get rid of it." As Williams continues to rebuild and put in place the measures that will deliver it back towards the front of the field, it could be the perfect environment for a young driver such as Sargeant to find their feet in the sport and grow alongside the team that has injected its faith into them. Otherwise, if rookies are tossed about from season to season with no time to grow their potential, impatient F1 teams will be responsible for destabilising the careers of drivers who have worked years to establish themselves. Do you think Logan Sargeant will earn a second season at Williams in 2024? Let us know in the comments below and by voting in the poll!

x
LATEST Red Bull reveal new Perez F1 role