Welcome at RacingNews365

Become part of the largest racing community in the United Kingdom. Create your free account now!

  • Share your thoughts and opinions about F1
  • Win fantastic prizes
  • Get access to our premium content
  • Take advantage of more exclusive benefits
Sign in
FIA

F1 fans torn over FIA handling of Norris penalty process

F1 fans have shared their opinion over the FIA right of review case lodged by McLaren over Lando Norris' penalty in Austin, and there is a striking lack of consensus.

Norris Austin
Article
To news overview © XPBimages

The FIA stewards rejected McLaren's right of review petition for failing to meet the required criteria to have the decision, that handed Lando Norris a decisive time penalty at the United States Grand Prix, re-opened.

In the closing stages of the race at the Circuit of the Americas, the McLaren driver attempted an overtake around the outside of Max Verstappen, but with both veering outside track limits, he was viewed to have completed the move off circuit.

The stewards quickly awarded him a five-second time penalty, which dropped him back behind the Red Bull - and off the podium - at the chequered flag.

This provoked McLaren into requesting the case be re-assessed, by way of the FIA right of review process, given the verdict was decided upon within a matter of laps and without team representation to argue its case - not to mention the drivers' and constructors' championship implications.

However, the Woking-based squad was not deemed to have met the threshold to have the penalty re-examined, something that has split opinion amongst the F1 community.

In a recent poll by RacingNews365, a plurality of respondents believed the FIA - and its stewards - had been correct in not forwarding the process o the next stage, as McLaren did not satisfy the requisite criteria.

However, that 40.84% vote share is only just clear of the 39.79% who believed the right of review should have been upheld.

Although, critically, that segment is split between those who feel the criteria is too strict and those who believe McLaren did surpass the high bar to have the petition accepted.

Please see the full results of the latest poll by RacingNews365 below. Let us know what you think by leaving a comment.

Were the stewards wrong to reject McLaren's right of review?

Answer Share of vote
Yes - the criteria is too strict 22.51%
No - McLaren did not satisfy the criteria outlined by the FIA 40.84%
Yes - McLaren did meet the criteria 17.28%
Unsure - the process is too complicated and should be changed 19.37%

Join the conversation!

x
STANDINGS 2024 F1 championship standings after Mexican Grand Prix